Jump to content
Xand

[Sig] Signature Rating Thread

Recommended Posts

I just made this, and yeah I know about the animation but I can't slow it down too much otherwise it messes up. So feedback or anything? :)

 

qfBcZpm.gif

Share this post


Link to post

I just made this, and yeah I know about the animation but I can't slow it down too much otherwise it messes up. So feedback or anything? :)

 

qfBcZpm.gif

 

This is actually my favorite sig that you've made. I don't think the animation is too bad either. The one thingis that some of the background stuff looks a little weird, but otherwise good

 

Rate mine.

 

The greninja looks funny (I think just a bad render), and the text doesn't flow too well. With simple sigs like this I think its generally better to only have one render in it

Share this post


Link to post

This is actually my favorite sig that you've made. I don't think the animation is too bad either. The one thingis that some of the background stuff looks a little weird, but otherwise good

 

 

Well thank you very much =3 Extremely pleased to hear that :) And the background, well don't even ask lol

Share this post


Link to post

here are 2 of my pokemon related signatures 

squirtle.png

dialgacopy.png

 

 

I like both of the signatures they would look better if they were bigger. For the secound one I would make the border much thinner. The border has too much attention. As far as detail and look they are well rendered. 8/10

 

I just made this, and yeah I know about the animation but I can't slow it down too much otherwise it messes up. So feedback or anything? :)

 

qfBcZpm.gif

 

 

I agree this is great signature. I like how you put a scratch on him. I also like the yellow flames on the bottem because its usually a color that takes all the attention. The only part that bothers me is the green flame underneth your name. Otherwise nice 9/10.

 

Gief opinions on mine? :3

 

<3

 

Ive always liked this signature. Whenever I am on the forums i see it and its one of the best I have seen. It has a nice dark theme and I like how the murkrow's wing goes off the side. 9/10

 

 

---

 

 

Any opinouns on my new siggy :)?

 

siggymemekcopy_zps5e19ad48.jpg

Share this post


Link to post

Any opinouns on my new siggy :)?

 

siggymemekcopy_zps5e19ad48.jpg

 

Well if I'm honest, I love the way the colors are in tune with each other and make an excellent array of colors, and the render is very fitting for signature itself, one tiny thing that does get me a little is the text may be too bright, just my opinion but definitely 9/10!! :D

Share this post


Link to post

I found it. First sig I ever used...then so on...

 

kkPRJF8.png

Credit:Deejaye

 

I like that it's not typical in shape, and the boarders of it. But the text seems a bit bland. I feel like more could have been done with this, which could have made it come out a lot better. I say 6/10.~ 

 

Rate my current? :3 

Share this post


Link to post

Hey, can I have my current one rated. ^w^

 

8/10, pretty creepy but it would look a lot nicer if it flowed on the edges better instead of stopping in a rectangle shape, sort of right on the left side.

 

Anyone rate?

aSh6XJ3.png

and

xQgC5Ye.png

Share this post


Link to post

Hey, can I have my current one rated. ^w^

 

0/10, 2spooky5me

 

also, smoki's critique of it is spot on imo

Share this post


Link to post

8/10, pretty creepy but it would look a lot nicer if it flowed on the edges better instead of stopping in a rectangle shape, sort of right on the left side.

 

Anyone rate?

aSh6XJ3.png

and

xQgC5Ye.png

 

don't really have anything to say on the 1st one, it's perfect imo 10/10

on the second one, i think the left side (beside the character) is a bit too light; id also remove the line on the left side[?] 8/10

Share this post


Link to post

8/10, pretty creepy but it would look a lot nicer if it flowed on the edges better instead of stopping in a rectangle shape, sort of right on the left side.

 

Anyone rate?

aSh6XJ3.png

and

xQgC5Ye.png

 

Text placement is bad in both of em
First one is over-sharpened and the focal in the second one doesn't blend, and the lightning doesn't affect it

1st one 7.5/10

2nd 7/10

 

Still better than most sigs i saw gj

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.