[Sig] Signature Rating Thread

[Hol]

 

I feel like the text looks weird. Thoughts?

[commendershadow]

Epic signatures guys! B)  

[Gilan]

 

I like it, but what do you guys think?

 

 

I feel like the text looks weird. Thoughts?

I'm not a real critic, but I would give it a 9/10 . The animation seems skippy/jumpy, if you know what I mean... (mainly on the left side of the gastly)

[tinnguyen]

 

vote mine 

[Gilan]

vote mine

Hmm... For the Mightyena one, I'm confused as to how the background relates to the pokemon (I have the same issue in my green Kingdra Gif. sig). The animation of the background is meh, I don't like the fact that the repeat is obvious and not fluid. Overall 5/10 from me.

For the Dragonite one. Again I don't understand the fire background with this pokemon (I associate it with the sky and clouds). The text animation is ok, but I'm not drooling over it (I feel like it would be better if it were smoother, instead of each letter changing each frame. Also, the first bracket of the clan tag seems messed up when it gets filled with red). The glow animation of the dnite should also recede instead of going out and then suddenly resetting. The overall picture looks grainy, but that may be because it is too big. All in all I would give a 4/10 for this one.

Just my opinion (I'm not an established critic whatsoever).

[Jate]

vote mine

6/10 needs to be smoother, and you just need to put more effort in instead of stealing backgrounds and slapping on some text.

2/10 doesn't fit as a sig, colors don't match animation is kinda ugly

[Gilan]

 

I like it, but what do you guys think?

please rate mine

[tinnguyen]

vote mine

[Hol]

Thoughts on this one?

 

[Heimann]

I don't like that gold parts on the pokemon, they stand out too much imo, and slightly scale back the animation so you can tell that says Burst not Rurst

Otherwise kawaii/10 as usual

[Parke]

 

yep... this happened

[iosifman]

 

How about this?

[Vaeldras]

Rate mine  :rolleyes:

[Hol]

 

yep... this happened

 

F her right in the pokeball.

[drpdrp97]

Go ahead and rate my crap sig.

 

Tell me what to do better though pris.

[Heimann]

Go ahead and rate my crap sig.

 

Tell me what to do better though pris.

Not sure if srs

[drpdrp97]

Not sure if srs

Only partially serious hue.

[Hol]

 

:3

[Jate]

vote mine

1/10

[tinnguyen]

Lol

[Sammier]

 

vote mine

This is not how this thread should work, u should rate others too.

[CaptainGrimm]

 

 

Not sure if sigs are worth selling on here,

 

If so what can they be traded for?

 

and Rate and let me know what you think :o

[tinnguyen]

vote mine

[tinnguyen]

[quote name="CaptainGrimm" post="856933" timestamp="1407002084"]

[img]http://i62.tinypic.com/66vhjm.png[/img]


Not sure if sigs are worth selling on here,

If so what can they be traded for?

and Rate and let me know what you think :o[/quote]
5/10

[quote name="iosifman" post="847190" timestamp="1405930153"]

[img]http://i.imgur.com/YNDh4Wx.gif[/img]

How about this?[/quote]
9/10

[quote name="xGilanx" post="839413" timestamp="1405045024"]

[img]http://s18.postimg.org/erejr0rex/Liberta_Text_Fade.gif[/img]

I like it, but what do you guys think?

I'm not a real critic, but I would give it a 9/10 . The animation seems skippy/jumpy, if you know what I mean... (mainly on the left side of the gastly)[/quote]
7/10

[Hol]

 

 

Not sure if sigs are worth selling on here,

 

If so what can they be traded for?

 

and Rate and let me know what you think :o

 

Maybe a 6/10.

Nice concept but it's too small and the resolution looks weird.