Jump to content

[Sig] Signature Rating Thread


Xand

Recommended Posts

  • 2 weeks later...

lBjrgFA.png 

(The Japanese was requested by the customer, not much I could do with it. Also, she's a vampire if you couldn't tell)

 

NZ5rfGx.png 

(demolished background because a destroyed city was one of the big battlegrounds in this anime)

 

vk4Wv5I.png 

(Used sci-fi font because the character is from Starcraft, which is a sci-fi game)

 

Rate these? (comments were left to clear any confusion if questions had arisen)

Link to comment
9 minutes ago, Argorok2017 said:

lBjrgFA.png 

(The Japanese was requested by the customer, not much I could do with it. Also, she's a vampire if you couldn't tell)

 

NZ5rfGx.png 

(demolished background because a destroyed city was one of the big battlegrounds in this anime)

 

vk4Wv5I.png 

(Used sci-fi font because the character is from Starcraft, which is a sci-fi game)

 

Rate these? (comments were left to clear any confusion if questions had arisen)

2
2
and -5
gross, stop, gg rekt

EDIT: kuro one is fire

Edited by DiDi
Link to comment
15 hours ago, Argorok2017 said:

lBjrgFA.png 

render is terrible, blood ruins the background

render has some weird outline 

text color is offputting

;looks like you slapped a render on a background and added text

0-2/10

 

NZ5rfGx.png 

same as above, except this render is ok

text is poor choice , color&font

looks like all you did was slap a render on a background again


2-3/10

vk4Wv5I.png 

render stands out too much

lightning on render does not match anything in the background

text is offputting

yet again slapping a render on a background and adding text

1-2/10

 

Rate these? (comments were left to clear any confusion if questions had arisen)

and stop slapping that black border on everything

Edited by Heimann
Link to comment
25 minutes ago, Heimann said:

and stop slapping that black border on everything

dayum, someone's an ass lmao. You say it's just slapping a render on a background then I can say the same about more than half of these sigs I've seen on here.

 

The reason I asked about a serious rating was because the person who rated it before is my friend who was trolling me, no need to be a uguu.

Link to comment

2.) If you're going to be negative, always give constructive criticism as to why you feel that way

3.) In relation to rule 2, if you are on the receiving end of negative constructive feedback, please try not to take offense

 

I gave you a serious rating. I could recreate any of those sigs you made within minutes, they literally look like you took stock backgrounds and plastered a render on them then added text and called it a day.

 

Sorry that reviewing your work makes me a 'uguu'

Link to comment
5 minutes ago, Heimann said:

2.) If you're going to be negative, always give constructive criticism as to why you feel that way

3.) In relation to rule 2, if you are on the receiving end of negative constructive feedback, please try not to take offense

 

I gave you a serious rating. I could recreate any of those sigs you made within minutes, they literally look like you took stock backgrounds and plastered a render on them then added text and called it a day.

 

Sorry that reviewing your work makes me a 'uguu'

No I've seen the other ratings you've given to other people, and you were nowhere near as much of an ass as you were for my ratings.

Link to comment
Just now, Argorok2017 said:

No I've seen the other ratings you've given to other people, and you were nowhere near as much of an ass as you were for my ratings.

If I was an ass I would of quoted soothe to describe your work.

 

Please stop being triggered, I didn't say it was shit, I didn't tell you to uninstall photoshop or w/e you use, I haven't bullied you, I gave you what you wanted.

 

A honest review.

AnkMJq9.gif

 

Link to comment
2 hours ago, Heimann said:

very simple

text seems off (outer glow)

no idea why you did a black border

 

4-10ish, nothing stands out to make you go 'wow'

 

thank you. first time using a fire background, so i have no idea if it's fine or what so.

i'm bad anyhow, though.

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...
On June 11, 2016 at 9:27 PM, Argorok2017 said:

lBjrgFA.png 

•Neon Pink font doesnt fit with the dark theme

•Render on top of Background

•Blood kinda distracts me from the only good part, the background 

 

NZ5rfGx.png 

•Render on top of a Background

•Why red font? Doesnt fit at all

•Bad font choice imo, but i never like fonts 

 

vk4Wv5I.png 

•Font looks nicer than the others

•Neon Blue?

•Render on a almost plain background

 

How you can improve:

•Your font distracts from the rest of the signature, use colors maybe from the render itself

•Renders look slapped on, try using different tools to make it feel layered.

on mobile soo i may have missed some thing, all in all i agree w/ the other critiques, 2-3/10 at the most. Work on layering your sigs and font choice/color/placement and you might be able to get something going

Link to comment

Welp I've done a few since those apparent shit ones, so here goes nothing (literally nothing)

 

fazt0dq.png

 

VmKcH7L.png

 

Vg5SWa6.png

 

XF88jTr.gif

(EDIT: my dumbass figured out how to link gifs)

 

I understand the fonts aren't the best, still working on fonts

Edited by Argorok2017
Rip me linking gifs
Link to comment
1 hour ago, Argorok2017 said:

 

 

fazt0dq.png

•Still a Render on a background

•Good Job on font color

VmKcH7L.png

•Very Plain

•Render on a background

•Font is hard to read, white might have been better

Vg5SWa6.png

•Best of the three

•Font is very hard to read

XF88jTr.gif

•Font distracts me from the sig

•Gif is short and moves fast 

•Im not a fan of gifs at all

the last two were definitely an improvement, the other two were the same

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.