According to your definition, anything you are given from donating is pay2win. You just said that when you get an advantage from donating, it's pay2win. I think you should rephrase your definition because almost anything is an advantage.
How are noobs going to beat a row of lv 100 trainers as NPCs on Route 1? The ONLY solution is to have the power to walk through them, and only fight them by approaching them.
I was about to say this should go in the already existing thread, but that guy keeps telling people to stop posting in his thread with splices, so go ahead.
This would encourage spam.
Post 1: Hey guys I'm getting closer to the best rank by posting this!
Post 2: trolololololol
Post 3: I LIEK PIE!
Post 4: I am so bred rt now. lol
Post 5: Mods, just, liek, close my thread, it's for the rank thingy.
And that is what happens when rank comes from posting.