Sashaolin

IGN: Kriliin

Yeah, like I said earlier, I could even consider another line-up more accurate than mine. Sorry for my lack of precision, I tried my best though. Good night mate.

I will not waste my time providing a justification for every single choice I made, I'm not the organizer in case you haven't realized. I already mentioned it at the bottom of page 1. I thought it was obvious that "joining date" meant "first appearances in the competitive scene" and not the "account creation date". Gunthug understood it that way though. My goal was to oppose performances >< appearances.

The simple reason you didn't get it after so many explanations and even asked for it. It's simple, I estimate if the player performed more in the OG or in the NG according to the others.

gbwead performed in both NG and OG, he could find his place in both line-ups just like LKrenz or Yubel for instance. I divided my line-ups the way I wanted, nobody prevented you to make yours, I could even consider another line-up more accurate than mine, stop acting like if I had imposed mine. Why bringing one more time the argument "he originally popped of in OG" and than asking "where did i sort people based on joining dates?" Players are sorted by performances in OG and NG, "being around for ages" or "popped of in OG" are therefore irrelevant.

You don't get it or you don't want to get it ? It's pretty simple, OG means Old Gen, it doesn't mean old players. The OG line-up should be the players who performed well before november 2017. NG means New Gen, it doesn't mean new players. The NG line-up should be the players who performed well after november 2017. This is the only consistent way to divide the 2 line-ups, you even suggested Madara and Mkns in your NG line-up while those 2 players were already playing before november 2017. Takens already said it, the joining date has nothing to do with this event, it's all about OG and NG legendary players.

What you are asking is "old players against new players" while this tournament is clearly about generations. Takens even said 16 legends of PokeMMO, there are no legendary new competitive players.

I don't think so, I think performances are more relevant than the joining dates. Most of the players who are performing well in NG already played in OG. It means that the NG line-up would be ridiculously less interesting than the OG one to me and many players who are not going to find a place in the OG line-up would be players who performed more than the NG players in the NG itself. All in all, it will reduce the quality of the event. For instance, enchanteur who will probably not be in the OG line-up could not be a in NG line-up while we are probably all agreeing he's one if not the player who performed the most in the NG.

Some of them were good in both OG and NG. I based my rankings on their performances during those gens, not on their joining dates.

What do you mean ? NG starts in november 2017

My tops : OG : Frags KingBowser Axoa YUBELLLLLLLLLLLL Raaidn NikhilR BurntZebra Walpayer NG : enchanteur ZhikoDark LKrenz MadaraSixSix gbwead ZDFire EpicVerde BlueBreath

She was an example of positivity. I'll miss you Roxxy!

It's full of sense, I explained it, you just don't get it, apparently too deep for superficial minds who made stigma based on inductions. I called it my point of view and never pretend it to be the best answer to coaching, it's a complex issue, it's not obvious contrary to what many people think here. I do not have the need or the desire to defend this point of view unlike you, I only intervened to denounce your misleading remarks. One more time, this analogy is completely inappropriate and irrelevant. If you don't see the difference between the possibility to prevent something and the total inability to prevent it, the difference between a society you're forced to take part and a game that you must register of your own free will or even the difference between brainstorming and murdering, I guess you're a lost cause. Thank you for showing to everyone what happens when someone is not satisfied by his own poor arguments, it directly leads to attacks ad hominem. I won the last PSL I took part as a player with a 7-2 ratio, I even kicked your ass that season but that's another story...